A quarterly index tracking 1ct lab-grown diamond prices against mined diamonds and moissanite from 2016 to 2026, revealing an 85-plus percent decline and actionable seller pricing strategies.
Published:
November 20, 2026
Author:
Yi Cui
There is no public, centralized spot exchange for a 1ct G/VS1 lab diamond. Unlike gold, no single screen gives every buyer the same executable price at the same moment.
A consumer can see a $350 virtual loose stone, a $900 branded stone, and a $2,000 store quote for a similar listing. They are not necessarily equivalent products or service levels.
Retail markup is part of the gap. In Q3 2025, Edahn Golan reported that US retailers paid an average of $180 per carat for a round, 1ct, IGI-certified lab diamond while the wholesale trading price was $73 per carat. The same report put the average gross margin for 1 to 3ct round lab diamonds at 75%. 6 A displayed retailer price is not the category’s market price.
Grading and make are just as important. GIA explains that value rests on cut, color, clarity, and carat weight; even subtle color differences can change value dramatically. Strong fluorescence can also make a stone look cloudy or oily, lowering value. 7
Geography adds another layer. An Indian cash-trade price, a US retail buying cost, a virtual US listing, and a branded US retail price are different points in the chain. They should not be collapsed into one number.
The non-obvious problem: most online “price comparisons” compare non-equivalent goods. A round with Excellent cut, no fluorescence, tight proportions, and an IGI or GIA report is not interchangeable with a looser-cut stone, a different clarity, another certification standard, or a fancy shape. Without a controlled specification, a lower quote may only prove that the cheaper item is different. GIA’s explanation of the 4Cs is the reason a controlled index is necessary, not an optional flourish. 7
Prices also move faster at wholesale than at retail. De Beers said in May 2025 that jewelry-sector lab-grown wholesale prices had fallen 90% since Lightbox launched in 2018, while retailers can take time to reset inventory and advertised prices. 8

At Branvas, we call this framework the Branvas Controlled-Spec Price Index, or CSPI. It is a transparent retail-reference series, not an exchange, appraisal, or promise that a buyer can transact at every plotted price.
Target controlled specification: round brilliant; 1.00ct plus or minus 0.05ct; G color; VS1 clarity; Excellent cut; IGI or GIA report; no fluorescence; 61% to 62% depth; and 56% to 58% table.
Benchmark comparators: the mined comparator holds the same target specification and GIA certification where available. The moissanite comparator is a 1ct-equivalent Charles & Colvard DEF/VVS1-style retail reference. Fancy shapes, fancy colors, melee, and uncertified stones are excluded.
What the public data can, and cannot, support: a true quarter-by-quarter G/VS1 transaction database is proprietary. Rapaport’s price list and TradeScreen are subscription products, while IDEX’s index is built from its inventory database and updated hourly. 9 10 This release does not claim historic retailer or Nivoda scrapes that cannot be shown.
Instead, the historical backbone is Paul Zimnisky’s public chart for a 1ct round, VS-clarity, near-colorless loose-stone retail sample. The chart itself is labeled as analysis and estimates. We digitized its plotted observations to the nearest $50, then cross-checked the 2020 and 2021 lab-to-natural ratios against Bain and AWDC’s published averages. 11 12 22 This is a comparable public proxy, not a reconstructed invoice series for literal G/VS1 stones.
For the current endpoint, CSPI uses PriceScope’s quality-graded live listing feed, current G/VS1 natural examples on Rare Carat, and Charles & Colvard’s 1ct moissanite range. 3 5 23 The direct-market source change is disclosed because it can sit below a full-service retail benchmark.
Frequency: quarterly updates from Q1 2016. This release presents 16 anchor quarters with a credible public observation or stated benchmark. It does not claim independently published controlled-spec numbers for every intervening quarter.
Moissanite limitation: no public historical quarterly series for the exact Charles & Colvard DEF/VVS1 equivalent was found. Rather than invent a smooth past trajectory, historical moissanite cells are marked not published. The Q2 2026 reference is included because it is a current, disclosed retail range.
Update rule: retain source URLs and the source date for each new observation; use like-for-like specs where possible; annotate any proxy, transition, or range midpoint; and never overwrite prior values silently.
We update this index quarterly. If you're a seller, bookmark this page. Sourcing decisions made on stale data cost margin.
Download the update-ready source table: Branvas CSPI data CSV.


| Quarter | Lab-Grown (1ct, G, VS1) Retail Avg. | Mined (1ct, G, VS1) Retail Avg. | Moissanite (1ct eq.) Retail Avg. | Lab/Mined Price Ratio | Key Market Event |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Q1 2016* | ~$5,350 | ~$6,500 | Not published | 82% | High-price era, limited gem-quality lab supply |
| Q4 2016* | ~$4,950 | ~$6,200 | Not published | 80% | Lab diamonds still priced close to mined |
| Q4 2017* | ~$4,300 | ~$6,200 | Not published | 69% | CVD adoption expands |
| Q2 2018* | ~$3,700 | ~$6,500 | Not published | 57% | Lightbox announces linear $800/ct pricing |
| Q4 2018* | ~$3,250 | ~$5,850 | Not published | 56% | Lightbox begins selling |
| Q4 2019* | ~$2,650 | ~$5,450 | Not published | 49% | CVD capacity and online inventory rise |
| Q2 2020* | ~$2,000 | ~$5,900 | Not published | 34% | COVID disruption, online jewelry accelerates |
| Q4 2020* | ~$2,000 | ~$6,050 | Not published | 33% | Demand rebound; Bain reports 35% average retail ratio |
| Q2 2021* | ~$1,900 | ~$6,300 | Not published | 30% | Post-COVID demand peak; Bain reports 30% ratio |
| Q4 2021* | ~$1,750 | ~$6,400 | Not published | 27% | Supply continues scaling |
| Q2 2022* | ~$1,650 | ~$6,650 | Not published | 25% | Mined-price peak, lab discount widens |
| Q4 2022* | ~$1,400 | ~$5,600 | Not published | 25% | Retail repricing gathers pace |
| Q2 2023† | ~$1,325 | ~$5,300 | Not published | 25% | Reported lab discounts reach 75% to 90% |
| Q2 2024‡ | $900 | ~$5,000 | Not published | 18% | Lightbox cuts D-F/VS/Excellent price to $900/ct |
| Q1 2025§ | $900 | ~$5,000 | Not published | 18% | Published ideal-round comparison; price collapse is mainstream news |
| Q2 2026¶ | ~$350 | ~$3,500 | ~$750 | 10% | 1ct wholesale firms, while larger stones stay under pressure |
* Historical public-proxy observation. Digitized to the nearest $50 from Zimnisky’s 1ct round, VS-clarity, near-colorless retail chart. It is the closest consistent public series, not a literal G/VS1 transaction record. The 2020 and 2021 ratios are corroborated by Bain/AWDC’s published 35% and 30% average retail ratios. 11 12 22
† Closest stated Q2 2023 comparison. CNBC quoted a $5,300 slightly-better-than-average 1ct natural diamond and reported market commentary that lab diamonds were 75% to 90% cheaper. 13
‡ Published quality benchmark, not a market average. Rapaport reported Lightbox’s D-F, VS, Excellent line at $900 per carat in 2024. The mined comparator is a nearest publicly reported comparable reference, so this row should be read as a directional anchor. 14
§ Published consumer comparison. The New York Times, quoting Paul Zimnisky in January 2025, reported a nice 1ct ideal round lab diamond at $900 versus about $5,000 for the natural equivalent. 1
¶ Current controlled-spec proxy. The lab figure is a direct-online G/VS1 benchmark informed by PriceScope’s live quality table and its stated 10% to 15% premium for Ideal/Super Ideal cuts. The mined figure is the midpoint of current 1ct G/VS1 direct-market examples around $3,386 to $3,605. The moissanite number is the midpoint of Charles & Colvard’s published $500 to $1,000 range. 3 5 23
Key-events legend: Lightbox’s 2018 $800-per-carat launch was a positioning signal, not a universal wholesale price. Bain documents the widening pandemic gap; GIA documents an estimated 4,000 to 6,000 CVD reactors in Surat; and De Beers announced its intended Lightbox closure in May 2025. 8 11 12 14 15

2016 to 2018: high-price era. Lab diamonds began this period as a premium alternative rather than a commodity. Zimnisky says a 1ct lab diamond sold only 10% below an equivalent natural diamond as recently as 2016. The public chart’s broader near-colorless/VS proxy shows a similar, if slightly wider, gap. 16
Supply was smaller, quality was less uniform, and US-facing distribution was still limited. The price premium had room to survive because a seller could frame lab-grown as a new kind of fine jewelry, not simply a manufactured input.
2018 to 2020: the Lightbox shock. In May 2018, De Beers announced Lightbox pricing of $200 for a quarter carat and $800 for 1ct. It also said its planned Oregon facility could eventually produce more than 500,000 rough carats a year. 17
The strategic point was clear: position lab-grown as affordable fashion jewelry, separate from mined diamond rarity. It did not instantly set every competitor’s price, but it made a high lab-grown premium harder to defend.
2020 to 2022: CVD scale plus COVID demand. The pandemic accelerated e-commerce and jewelry demand. Bain says 2020 online diamond retail reached about 20% of sales, while lab-grown production reached 6 to 7 million carats. 11
Demand temporarily absorbed more supply, but capacity continued expanding. GIA estimates that China produced about 3 million gem-quality lab-grown carats in 2020, India about 1.5 million, and the United States about 1 million. 15
2022 to 2024: the price collapse. The price curve stopped looking like a luxury-gem curve and started looking like a manufacturing curve. More Indian and Chinese capacity, lower equipment costs, marketplace competition, and retail price transparency pushed down the wholesale floor.
Paul Zimnisky reported CVD machines in India available for under $100,000 versus as much as $300,000 in 2019. That is a decline of at least two-thirds in the cited equipment price. He also estimated that India and China together accounted for nearly three-quarters of global lab-diamond jewelry production by volume. 16
The market response was uneven. In 2024 Lightbox cut its D-F, VS, Excellent price from $1,500 to $900 per carat. In May 2025, De Beers said it planned to close Lightbox as part of its strategy to focus on natural diamonds and industrial synthetic applications. 8 14
2024 to 2026: floor-finding, not a broad rebound. The best current evidence is nuanced. Golan’s Q2 2026 wholesale index was still down 13% year over year and 96% from July 2018, but 1ct rounds were up 1% in the quarter. Large stones were still falling faster: 1.50 to 1.99ct down 11% year over year, and 2ct down 20%. 2
That supports a split outlook. Smaller HPHT goods may firm, while bigger stones remain exposed because capacity has concentrated in the sizes consumers now prefer. This is evidence of segmentation, not proof of a durable bottom.
Contrarian insight: the collapse is not evidence that lab-grown diamonds failed as a product. It is the expected outcome when a manufactured product reaches industrial scale. The useful comparison is not diamond versus diamond. It is lab-grown diamonds versus technologies such as solar panels, flat-screen displays, or batteries, where costs can fall as cumulative output, process knowledge, and competition grow.
Wright’s Law describes that mechanism: unit costs fall at a roughly consistent rate as cumulative production rises. Our World in Data cites solar as a classic example, with price falling about 20% for every doubling of cumulative capacity. That is an analogy for the manufacturing mechanism, not a forecast that diamonds will follow solar’s exact rate. 18

CVD equipment cost and productivity improved. The clearest published equipment comparison is Zimnisky’s: under $100,000 in India versus as much as $300,000 in 2019. That supports the commonly repeated 60% to 70% capex decline, but it is an industry observation, not a universal equipment price list. 16
China and India created manufacturing scale. GIA’s production estimates and Surat reactor count show why supply is no longer constrained by a handful of specialty producers. GIA also notes that most lab-grown diamonds it now sees are CVD-grown. 15
The cost stack is fundamentally different. Lab diamonds still require energy, capital, cutting, polishing, grading, logistics, and retail service. They do not require mine discovery, extraction, or geological scarcity. That removes a cost and risk layer, but does not make production free.
Certification made the product easier to compare, not magically free to produce. IGI’s role in lab-grown reports and GIA’s growing submission volumes make online merchandising more standardized. GIA says it now receives more CVD-grown submissions per day than it once received in an entire year. 15 The careful interpretation is that certification lowers buyer friction and widens distribution. We did not find a public apples-to-apples IGI-versus-GIA fee series proving that report pricing itself caused the collapse.
De Beers changed the category signal. Lightbox’s $800 launch, its 2024 reductions, and the 2025 closure announcement all reinforced the message that mass-market lab diamonds should track production economics rather than mined-diamond scarcity. 8 14 17
In our experience sourcing for private-label jewelry brands, the wholesale floor for a 1ct IGI lab-grown has moved faster than almost any other material we track, which is exactly why we built the CSPI.

Worked example specification: round brilliant, 1.00ct, G color, VS1 clarity, Excellent cut, IGI or GIA certified.
| Stone Type | Wholesale Est. | Typical Retail | Markup Multiple | Resale Value (Est. 5yr) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mined diamond | Not publicly disclosed for this exact stone | ~$3,400 to $3,600 direct-market examples | Not publishable from the source set | No guaranteed percentage; resale offers often sit below original retail |
| Lab-grown diamond | ~$73 trading price / ~$180 US retailer cost for closest 1ct IGI round proxy | ~$350 direct-online CSPI proxy; branded retail can be higher | ~1.9x of retailer cost, or ~4.8x of Indian trading price, using non-identical market points | Low-liquidity market; do not assume a reliable five-year percentage |
| Moissanite, DEF/VVS1 style | Not publicly disclosed | ~$500 to $1,000 for 1ct | Not publicly disclosed | No standardized secondary-market reference; assume negligible for pricing decisions |
This table is deliberately more conservative than a familiar “wholesale times markup equals retail” formula. A public 1ct G/VS1 mined wholesale transaction price is not available in the source set, so we do not reverse-engineer one from a retail listing. Rapaport explains that its price list is a benchmark and that final transaction prices apply a discount, often 10% to 30%; the actual list and matched transaction data are subscription products. 9
The lab row also needs careful reading. Golan’s $73 trading price and $180 retailer cost are for a broader IGI-certified 1ct round set, not the exact G/VS1 cut geometry above. They are useful transparency markers, not a quote for your purchase order. 6
On resale, certainty is more valuable than a false percentage. One retailer guide puts lab resale at 30% to 40% of purchase price, while JCK quotes a dealer saying the resale value is effectively only in the mounting after the price collapse. Those claims are not compatible enough to support a universal “under 10%” rule. The practical conclusion is low liquidity and weak price confidence, especially compared with buying new. 19 20
Lab-grown resale is low not because the stones are optically inferior. It is low because a secondary seller competes with new production whose price keeps falling. The structural parallel is refurbished electronics: when new supply becomes cheaper and better, the primary market sets a floor the used market struggles to beat.
Mined diamonds also should not be sold as investments. StoneAlgo notes that many jewelers and websites offer around 50% of original price in resale, and any outcome depends on cut quality, documentation, demand, and the original retail markup. 4

Moissanite remains materially cheaper than a premium branded lab diamond, although the gap narrows against direct-online lab inventory. Charles & Colvard says a 1ct moissanite typically costs $500 to $1,000, while its published comparison places a similar lab-grown diamond at $1,500 or more. That is a retailer-branded comparison, not a statement that every direct lab listing costs that much. 5
The products are not the same material. Diamond is Mohs 10. Charles & Colvard lists moissanite at Mohs 9.25 to 9.50, which is still durable for daily wear. Moissanite has a higher refractive index and more dispersion, which creates more rainbow fire. Some buyers love that high-sparkle look. Others prefer diamond’s light pattern. 5
Moissanite tends to win for budget-first buyers, fashion jewelry, stackable rings, and DTC collections that need a strong entry price. Lab-grown tends to win in bridal, milestone gifting, and situations where a customer specifically wants a diamond with a lab-grown origin claim.
We work with sellers who use moissanite and lab-grown in their catalog for different price tiers, and the positioning conversation matters as much as the price gap.
If you're building a jewelry brand and trying to decide which stone category to anchor your catalog around, explore how Branvas structures multi-stone catalogs →.

1. Do not anchor the brand to stone price. The stone cost matters, but the durable margin comes from design, packaging, content, trust, service, and a coherent reason to buy from your brand. Falling lab costs can improve margin without a higher customer price, provided the savings do not become a race to the bottom.
2. Use moissanite as the volume play and lab-grown as the positioning play. An entry moissanite line can offer visual impact at a comfortable price. A lab-grown line can support a fine-jewelry or bridal positioning. The names, product pages, imagery, and price ladder should make the difference understandable.
3. Sell the value story, not a long string of specs. Customers need enough specification detail to trust the product. They do not buy a proposal ring because they memorized table percentages. Explain what Excellent cut, a grading report, and the chosen stone category mean for the look, durability, and budget.
4. Handle resale honestly, then move on. Resale is relevant for some bridal shoppers but rarely central to fashion jewelry. Do not promise an investment outcome, and do not let the issue bury the immediate value of a design the customer will enjoy wearing.
5. Re-price every quarter. A 2024 cost sheet can leave a seller overpriced against direct competitors or can conceal margin that could fund better creative, customer service, or paid acquisition. Keep a dated sourcing log, set a margin floor by category, and revise hero-SKU pricing in a cadence rather than reacting to every social-media quote.
At Branvas, we see the best private-label catalogs separate commodity input costs from customer-facing value. The aim is not to hide price. It is to make the price intelligible.
Branvas helps jewelry brands source lab-grown and moissanite stones at wholesale, build private-label packaging, and ship blind directly to customers, so you focus on selling, not logistics. See how it works →
Calculate your potential margins with our Profit Calculator →

Bookmark this page or follow Branvas Academy for quarterly updates: branvas.com/academy

Q: What is the current price of a 1 carat lab-grown diamond?
A: For a controlled round, G/VS1, Excellent-cut loose stone, current direct-online references are roughly $350 to $900. The range is wide because cut quality, lab report, source country, retailer service, and marketplace model all matter. A broader live 1ct round lab index was about $525 in September 2026, while branded sellers can quote more. Treat any single price as a quote for that listing, not an industry-wide spot price. 3 21
Q: Why have lab-grown diamond prices dropped so much?
A: Capacity scaled faster than retail demand. GIA documents large Chinese and Indian production, including an estimated 4,000 to 6,000 CVD reactors in Surat. Zimnisky reported lower CVD-equipment costs, and De Beers said lab-grown jewelry wholesale values had declined 90% since 2018. The result is a manufactured product moving closer to its production cost, with online competition passing more of that decline to buyers. 8 15 16
Q: Do lab-grown diamonds hold their value?
A: They have limited and uncertain resale liquidity. There is no mature, standardized secondary market that can reliably price a lab diamond against rapidly falling new-production costs. Published resale claims conflict, so a universal five-year percentage would be misleading. Buy a lab-grown diamond for its appearance, durability, and lower upfront price, not as an investment. Mined diamonds can also resell below original retail, especially after a high initial markup. 4 19 20
Q: Is moissanite cheaper than lab-grown diamonds?
A: Often yes, especially against premium branded lab diamonds. Charles & Colvard puts a typical 1ct moissanite at $500 to $1,000. Direct online lab-grown inventory has become cheap enough that the categories can overlap, so the right choice is not only about price. Moissanite offers more rainbow fire and Mohs 9.25 to 9.50 durability; lab-grown offers a real diamond with diamond’s optical profile and Mohs 10 hardness. 5
Q: Will lab-grown diamond prices continue to fall in 2026?
A: The evidence points to segmentation rather than one answer for every size. Golan’s Q2 2026 wholesale index fell 13% year over year, but 1ct round wholesale prices rose 1% in the quarter. Larger sizes still fell more sharply. De Beers expected lab-grown jewelry cost and price to fall further, while Golan sees smaller-stone pricing firming as HPHT rough costs rise. Update your quote rather than relying on a 2024 rule of thumb. 2 8