.avif)
POD store owners can add high-margin jewelry without inventory or workflow changes, using made-to-order fulfillment and strategic merchandising to boost AOV significantly.
Updated:
February 11, 2026
Author：
Yi Cui
For ambitious print-on-demand (POD) store owners, hitting a revenue ceiling is a common frustration. You’ve optimized your designs, dialed in your marketing, and built a loyal following for your apparel. But growth stalls. The logical next step is to expand your product catalog, but most options—like adding more apparel categories—introduce operational complexity, new supplier relationships, and potential inventory risk. What if you could add jewelry to your POD store and open up a second, high-margin profit engine without changing your fulfillment workflow?
This isn’t just a hypothetical; it’s a proven strategy that top e-commerce entrepreneurs are using to increase their average order value (AOV) and customer lifetime value. The stakes are high: without a strategic product expansion, your brand risks stagnation. With the wrong one, you could dilute your brand and hurt your margins. This article provides a complete roadmap. You'll see three proven integration models, five exact merchandising placements that convert, and a step-by-step guide to integrating a starter jewelry assortment into your Shopify store.
Adding a new product category requires careful consideration, but jewelry stands out as a uniquely powerful choice for POD apparel brands. It aligns perfectly with the POD ethos of low-risk, high-reward product testing and offers a seamless fit in terms of audience, aesthetics, and profitability.
First, the margins are compelling. While most POD sellers target profit margins between 20-40% for apparel [1], engraved and made-to-order jewelry can command significantly higher margins, often between 30-60% or more [2]. This is because jewelry, especially personalized pieces, has a high perceived value. It’s lightweight, which keeps shipping costs low, and its small size makes it an easy impulse add-on to an existing order.
Second, there is a strong audience and aesthetic overlap. The same customers buying your graphic tees, hoodies, and streetwear are already purchasing jewelry. In 2025, online jewelry sales are expected to surpass $40 billion, with Generation Z and Millennials driving 70% of those purchases [6]. These are the core demographics for most POD brands. By offering minimalist, on-trend jewelry that complements your apparel, you’re not just selling another product; you’re enhancing your brand’s lifestyle appeal.
Finally, and most critically, adding jewelry doesn’t have to complicate your operations. With the right partner, you can offer a full line of jewelry with zero inventory and direct-to-customer shipping, preserving the hands-off fulfillment model that makes POD so attractive. As we’ll explore, modern fulfillment models for jewelry are designed to integrate seamlessly with your existing store.
Jewelry offers higher margins, aligns with existing POD audiences, and can be added without increasing operational complexity, making it the perfect second product category for apparel-focused POD stores.
The beauty of adding jewelry to a POD store in 2026 is the variety of low-lift fulfillment models available. You don’t need to handle inventory, manage packaging, or ship orders yourself. Here are the three most common models, each with its own pros and cons.
This is the most traditional dropshipping model. You partner with a supplier who stocks a wide range of jewelry, and you list their products on your store. When a customer places an order, you forward it to the supplier, who then ships the product directly to the customer. This model is excellent for testing a wide variety of styles to see what resonates with your audience.
This model is the closest to a true POD workflow. You partner with a company that creates jewelry on demand—often with options for engraving or personalization—and ships it directly to your customer. This is the model Branvas uses. It offers the highest level of quality control and the fastest shipping times, as products are often made and shipped from domestic facilities. In our experience at Branvas, this model is ideal for brands that want to offer a curated, high-quality jewelry line that feels like a natural extension of their brand.
In a hybrid model, you might work with your existing POD provider for apparel and a separate made-to-order partner for jewelry. This approach allows you to create curated product bundles, such as a t-shirt and necklace set. While this can be a powerful merchandising tactic, it may require apps to sync orders and can sometimes result in separate shipments for the customer. However, the AOV lift from bundles often outweighs the minor logistical complexity.
Model TypeOperational LiftMargin %Shipping TimeBest ForDropship Jewelry SuppliersLow-Medium20-50%5-15 daysTesting the market with a wide variety of stylesMade-to-Order (Direct Shipping)Low30-60%3-7 daysBrands focused on quality and fast fulfillmentHybrid (POD Apparel + Jewelry)MediumVaries5-15 days (synced)Creating curated bundles and gift sets
With several models to choose from, selecting the right supplier is critical. To help with this decision, we developed The POD Accessory Fit Matrix. This scoring rubric helps you evaluate potential partners based on the criteria that matter most for a POD business.
Criterion1 (Low Fit)3 (Medium Fit)5 (High Fit)WeightMargin CompatibilityLow margins (<20%)Moderate margins (20-40%)High margins (>40%)30%Shipping OverlapSeparate fulfillment, long lead timesIntegrated fulfillment, moderate lead timesDirect-to-customer, fast shipping (3-5 days)25%Audience AestheticMismatched style, requires new audienceSome overlap, appeals to a segmentPerfect match, enhances existing brand aesthetic20%Operational LiftHigh effort, new workflows requiredModerate effort, some new processesLow effort, integrates into existing workflows15%Supplier ReliabilityUnproven, poor reviews, no integrationEstablished, mixed reviews, manual integrationProven, great reviews, seamless app integration10%
To use the matrix, score each potential partner on a scale of 1-5 for each criterion, multiply by the weight, and sum the results. A higher score indicates a better fit. We've seen founders hesitate because they assume jewelry requires new supplier vetting, but that's a solvable problem with the right partner model.
Once you’ve selected a partner and a product assortment, the next step is merchandising. How you present jewelry to your customers will make or break your success. In our experience working with POD sellers at Branvas, the biggest barrier isn't logistics—it's merchandising placement. Here are the five most effective placements to upsell accessories for print on demand.
This is the most common and effective placement. On the product page of your best-selling t-shirts and hoodies, feature a “Pairs well with” or “Complete the look” section showcasing complementary jewelry. Shopify’s own data shows that personalized recommendations can increase conversions by up to 4.5 times [5]. This is a low-friction way to introduce your new product line to customers who are already in a buying mindset.
Once a customer has added an item to their cart, they have shown a strong intent to purchase. This is the perfect moment to offer a small, impulse-buy item like a minimalist ring or a simple chain bracelet. Using a cart upsell app, you can configure a pop-up or an in-cart offer that says, “Add this for just $25.” This tactic can increase AOV by 15-20% or more.
After a customer completes their purchase, you can present them with a one-time offer on the thank-you page. This is a surprisingly effective strategy for jewelry. Based on our data at Branvas, post-purchase upsells for jewelry convert at a surprisingly high rate, often between 5-8%, because the customer has already committed to the main purchase and trusts your brand. An offer like, “Add our best-selling necklace to your order for 20% off—no extra shipping,” is hard to resist.
Integrate jewelry into your existing email and SMS marketing. For browse abandonment flows, if a customer viewed a t-shirt, send them an email showcasing that t-shirt paired with a piece of jewelry. For welcome series, introduce your brand as a lifestyle brand that offers both apparel and accessories. This reinforces the idea that jewelry is a core part of your brand, not an afterthought.
Create dedicated bundles that pair a best-selling apparel item with a piece of jewelry for a discounted price. A “Streetwear Starter Kit” with a hoodie and a chain necklace, for example, can significantly lift AOV. A 2025 Shopify report highlights product bundling as a key strategy for increasing cart value [4].
of jewelry (4-6 SKUs) immediately often performs better than 'testing' with a single SKU. A single jewelry item can look like an afterthought. A small, curated collection signals a deliberate brand extension, encouraging customers to browse and bundle. This aligns with findings that personalized recommendations and product bundling significantly increase conversion rates [5].
When you first expand your POD product catalog, you don’t need a massive jewelry collection. At Branvas, we’ve noticed that POD audiences respond better to minimalist jewelry designs than intricate styles—likely due to brand aesthetic carryover. A curated starter assortment of 4-6 SKUs is enough to make an impact. Here are our recommendations:
A chain necklace in a minimalist style, measuring 16"–18", is a versatile, unisex piece that complements almost any neckline. It's a safe, low-return-rate item that appeals to a broad audience. Hoop earrings in small to medium sizes (20–30mm) are a timeless classic and an everyday staple for many customers. They have a high perceived value and pair well with both streetwear and more casual looks. A signet ring or band ring (adjustable or in common sizes like 7–9) taps into a major trend, especially among Gen Z and Millennial audiences, and an adjustable or common-sized option minimizes sizing issues.
A bracelet in a chain or beaded style (7"–8") is a perfect cart add-on. It has a low production cost and can be priced attractively as an impulse buy. A pendant necklace with a geometric or symbolic design allows you to inject your brand's personality into your jewelry line. A pendant that reflects your brand's niche—such as a lightning bolt for a streetwear brand or a lotus for a yoga brand—can be a powerful storytelling tool. As an optional sixth SKU, consider an anklet with an adjustable chain. Anklets are an emerging trend for 2025 and offer a way to stand out in a less competitive accessory space.
Ready to get started? Here’s a step-by-step guide to integrating jewelry into your Shopify store.
For POD sellers who want a turnkey solution, Branvas offers a curated jewelry line designed for DTC brands—with direct shipping, no MOQs, and styles optimized for apparel audiences. You can integrate Branvas via our Shopify app and have a jewelry line live in your store in under an hour.
To illustrate the power of this strategy, let’s look at a composite example based on several Branvas clients. “Retrograde Threads,” a Shopify POD store specializing in retro-futuristic graphic tees, was experiencing flat revenue growth. They wanted to increase AOV without the headache of managing inventory.
Using the POD Accessory Fit Matrix, they chose a made-to-order jewelry partner that offered fast, direct-to-customer shipping. They launched a focused, four-piece collection: a silver chain necklace, a signet ring, simple hoop earrings, and a Saturn-pendant necklace that tied into their space theme.
They implemented two key merchandising tactics: a “Complete the Look” cross-sell on their top 5 t-shirt product pages and a post-purchase upsell offering the Saturn necklace for 20% off. Within 60 days, their AOV increased by 18%, and their overall store conversion rate saw a 5% lift. In the second month, jewelry accounted for 12% of their total revenue. This demonstrates that a strategic jewelry addition is not just an add-on, but a significant revenue driver.
While adding jewelry is a powerful strategy, there are a few common pitfalls to avoid:
The first mistake is mismatched aesthetics. Don't just add any jewelry to your store. Ensure the style, materials, and branding align with your core apparel offering to maintain brand coherence. The second is ignoring merchandising. Simply adding jewelry to a collection page is not enough. You must proactively merchandise it through cross-sells, upsells, and bundles to drive visibility and conversions.
The third mistake is complicating fulfillment. A common question we get at Branvas is about shipping. The key is to find a partner that ships directly to the customer, so your fulfillment workflow doesn't change at all. Avoid partners that require you to handle shipping or introduce new logistics processes. Finally, many sellers make the mistake of not promoting their jewelry line. Treat your jewelry line like a real product launch. Announce it to your email list, post about it on social media, and run ads to drive awareness and initial sales momentum.
To implement the merchandising strategies discussed, you’ll need a few key tools. Here are some of the best apps for Shopify POD upsells:
Bold Upsell is a powerful app for creating both cross-sells and upsells on the product page and in the cart, making it a versatile choice for comprehensive merchandising. Zipify OneClickUpsell specializes in post-purchase upsells that can be added to an order with a single click, streamlining the checkout experience. ReConvert is a comprehensive thank-you page builder that allows you to create sophisticated post-purchase upsell funnels with advanced customization options. Bundler is an app for creating classic bundles, mix-and-match bundles, and volume discounts, perfect for encouraging larger purchases.
Alternatively, you can work with a direct jewelry partner like Branvas, which provides a fully integrated solution that includes not just the products but also merchandising support and best practices.
Can I add jewelry to my POD store without holding inventory?
Yes, absolutely. By using a dropship or made-to-order fulfillment model, you can sell jewelry without ever holding inventory. The partner company manufactures and ships the products directly to your customers.
What's the best jewelry supplier for Shopify POD stores?
The “best” supplier depends on your needs. For the widest variety, a dropship supplier might be best. For quality, speed, and a true POD experience, a made-to-order partner like Branvas is ideal. Use the POD Accessory Fit Matrix to evaluate your options.
How do I cross-sell jewelry on product pages in Shopify?
You can use Shopify’s built-in “Related Products” feature, but for more control, an app like Bold Upsell or a similar cross-sell app is recommended. These apps allow you to manually select which jewelry items to display on specific apparel product pages.
Do I need a separate fulfillment partner for jewelry?
Yes, you will likely need a separate partner that specializes in jewelry. Your current apparel POD provider probably doesn’t offer a jewelry line. However, the goal is to find a jewelry partner whose fulfillment process integrates seamlessly with your store, so it doesn’t feel like a separate workflow.
What jewelry styles convert best for POD apparel audiences?
Minimalist and symbolic styles tend to perform best. Think simple chains, geometric pendants, and classic hoops. These styles complement graphic tees and hoodies without overpowering them. According to Shopify, engraved and personalized jewelry also has very high profit margins due to its emotional value [2].
For POD store owners, adding jewelry is more than just a product line extension—it’s a strategic move to increase revenue, boost AOV, and deepen your brand’s lifestyle appeal. With modern, made-to-order fulfillment partners, it’s now possible to add jewelry to a POD store with zero inventory and no changes to your existing workflow. By choosing the right partner, curating a smart starter assortment, and implementing proven merchandising tactics, you can unlock a powerful new profit engine for your business.
If you're ready to expand your POD store with zero-inventory jewelry, explore Branvas's direct-ship program—designed specifically for DTC sellers who want curated jewelry without the operational lift.
[1] Printful. (2026, January 14). Print-on-demand statistics in 2026: Market data + insights.
[2] Shopify. (2025, December 4). 25 Bestselling Print-On-Demand Products (2026).
[3] Printify. (2025, November 26). Print-on-demand trends 2026: What’s selling and what’s next.
[4] Shopify. (2025, August 6). Upselling: 7 Proven Strategies to Boost AOV in 2026.
[6] Immerss. (2025, November 21). 2025 Jewelry E-Commerce Trends.